Unrelenting Snowstorms Pose Major Roof Collapse Risk in New England

By Alexa Lewis, AccuWeather.com Staff Writer

February 14,2015; 10:52PM,EST

 

 

Heavy snow accumulation is causing roof collapses across New England as back-to-back storms are burying the region with near-record amounts of snow.
In Rockland, Massachusetts, a portion of the Piano Mill's roof crumbled into a showroom this month, coming close to damaging a piano priced at $500,000. However, an even larger concern is when people are inside.
New England has seen a highly unusual amount of snow this month, according to AccuWeather.com Meteorologist Tom Kines, with 2 to 4 feet accumulating in the Boston area, other parts of Massachusetts and along the eastern New England coast.

"The snow is not going to be melting any time soon," Meteorologist Stephanie Dunten told the Associated Press. "We recommend homeowners scrape any snow off their roofs to avoid overloading, as we've already seen a few roofs collapsing."
AccuWeather Forensic Meteorologist Steve Wistar said that for safety reasons home and business owners should hire contractors to remove the snow or use rakes if the roof is not too high.
Bong Wang uses a snow rake to try and clean an ice jam from the roof of his home, Saturday Jan. 9, 2010, in Omaha, Neb. (AP Photo/Dave Weaver)
"If the roof is sagging it has to be handled very carefully because the added weight of people shoveling the snow could cause a problem," said Anthony Maiocco from Maiocco Structural Engineering. "And a contractor would have more experience with safety."
In the Northeast, roofs are generally designed to support 30 pounds per square foot, Wistar said, but some roofs are built to support 40, 50 or even 100 pounds per square foot, according to the ASCE Standard Handbook.
"But 30 pounds per square foot is just a starting point, then you have to factor in the other variables," Wistar said.
The amount of snow accumulation is not always the best guide to determining how much weight snow is putting on a roof.

Weight of Snow
The inches of snow accumulation do not directly dictate the weight that is placed on a roof. The weight of snow is actually dependent on the water content, Wistar said.
One inch of water weighs 5.2 pounds per square foot, and snow can have different distributions of water content, which depend on a number of variables including outside temperature.

Wet snow weighs more than dry snow because it has a higher water content.
Dry, powdery snow weighs less and its dusty, flaky texture makes it prone to drifting, which is ideal for any roof designed for drifting.
But roofs with external roof units, such as air conditioning or parapet units, are more prone to uneven weight distribution as the snow drifts against these units instead of blowing off the roof. When powdery snow is blown in the wind, the snowflakes break apart and when they resettle they actually become more dense adding to the weight around rooftop units, Wistar said.
"When snow weighs 10 pounds per square foot that is okay, but when it starts getting into the 20s then it can be a concern for a roof," Wistar said.
Over time snow compacts and settles down, meaning the snow won't be as deep but the weight will be the same. What was once one foot of snow may become less, but the weight will not change, Wistar said.
And when temperatures rise and snowfall turns to rainfall, the snow already coating rooftops can become saturated and heavy with rain.
(iStock/Thinkstock)
When the snow does begin to melt away, it can refreeze around gutters and drains under lower temperatures, trapping more melting water on the roof. The trapped water can not only leak into the home's interior, but it causes further stress on the roof.
Different roof designs are built to cope with snow differently, each one with both advantages and disadvantages.
Sloped Roofs
Gable roofs, which have two sloping sides, can become problematic in heavy wind conditions, when snow will blow from one side and settle on the other.
Some slopped roofs, with enough slope and that are short enough, can allow snow to blow from one side and then onto the ground.
But slopped roofs are also prone to ice dams, which can cause interior and roof damage.
No house insulation is perfect and as heat escapes up through the middle of the roof, it can melt away the lower layers of the snowpack. As this water migrates away from the heated center and reaches the cold eaves, or edges, of the house it can quickly freeze, Wistar said.
Other variables such as solar radiation and the home's orientation toward sunlight can impact how prone the house is to ice dams. The snow will melt in the sun but refreeze in the shade.
(iStock/Thinkstock)
An ice dam can cause damage to the drainage system and gutter as it prevents other water run-off from escaping. As water is backed up behind the thick dam, it can infiltrate into the home's interior and keep unwanted weight on top of the roof.
"When you have an ice dam, you block water from going anywhere and it can sink back under the roof," said Wister. "And anywhere that water collects and freezes, the solid ice is going to be heavier."
This heavy ice can also cause stress and damage to the roof, Wistar said.
RELATED:
AccuWeather.com Winter Weather Center
AccuWeather.com MinuteCast ® for Your Precise Location
Boston Turns to Snow Farms, Melting Trucks in Desperate Efforts to Unclog City Streets
A-frame roofs, which have very steep slopes, speed up water run-off so that it doesn't have the opportunity to refreeze.
However, these sloped roofs typically aren't feasible for large industrial buildings, hospitals or any other large building.
Flat Roofs
A car drives by Schmidt's Collision and Glass after the roof collapsed after taking on heavy snow during this week's lake-effect snowstorms on Saturday, Nov. 22, 2014, in Hamburg, New York. Western New York continues to dig out from the heavy snow dropped by this week by lake-effect snowstorms. (AP Photo/Mike Groll)
While most roofs are not entirely flat, roofs with a level appearance allow for snow to easily blow off the roof. However, some of these roofs have external systems on the roof, including air conditioning and parapet units, which encourage snow drifts to settle around the unit.
These roofs are also less prone to ice dam formation, but the draining systems on top of the roof can freeze over trapping melting water on the roof.
Wistar said that there really is no ideal roof type to battle winter weather, and it all really comes down to the type of snow and the amount of wind.